Is your workplace pension scheme quietly costing you money?
While you focus on running your business, outdated pension arrangements could be silently eroding value for your employees, and you could be spending money unnecessarily on administration costs.
Research shows that almost a quarter of SME employers have never reviewed their pension scheme, and more than half have not reviewed their default fund. This lack of review means businesses could be missing significant opportunities to improve returns, reduce costs, and enhance this crucial employee benefit.
When was the last time you took a close look at your workplace pension?
If you can’t remember, you’re not alone – but you might be facing some serious red flags that demand immediate attention.
Red Flag #1: You haven’t implemented pension salary exchange (Or you’ve done it ineffectively)
Pension salary exchange (sometimes called salary sacrifice) represents one of the most effective ways to maximise pension contributions while reducing costs for both employers and employees. This arrangement allows employees to exchange part of their salary for pension contributions, reducing National Insurance contributions for both parties.
The benefits are substantial:
- Employers can reduce employer National Insurance contributions at the new employer NI rate of 15% (increased from 13.8% starting April 2025) on exchanged amounts.
- Employees benefit from NI savings at their applicable rate (typically 10% for earnings between the Primary Threshold and Upper Earnings Limit).
These savings can be reinvested to boost pension pots or shared between the employer and the employee.
However, implementation matters. A poorly executed salary exchange programme can create confusion, reduce take-up rates, and fail to deliver the promised benefits.
For instance, research by Scottish Widows last year revealed that 22% of workers had never heard of salary sacrifice, and 40% felt simplifying the concept should be a priority for employers. This highlights the need for clear communication to ensure greater understanding and participation.
Talk To Us
Red Flag #2: Your default fund structure hasn’t been reviewed recently
Default funds – where employees’ contributions automatically go unless they choose otherwise – are the backbone of workplace pensions. Yet many default funds were designed for a pension landscape that has moved on.
Since the introduction of pension freedoms in 2015, there has been a significant shift in how individuals access their retirement savings. Before these reforms, approximately 75% of defined contribution (DC) pensions were used to purchase annuities. An annuity is a financial product that converts your pension savings into a guaranteed, regular income for life, or for a fixed period, providing a predictable stream of income in retirement.
However, by last year, this figure had declined to just 10% of all pots accessed, with many individuals opting for flexible income options such as drawdown. Pension drawdown, also known as flexible retirement income or income drawdown, allows you to access your pension savings flexibly, taking income as and when you need it while keeping the remaining funds invested.
This shift highlights the growing preference for flexibility in retirement income, making it essential for employers and pension providers to offer tailored solutions that align with employees’ evolving needs and preferences as they approach retirement.
Is your default fund strategy still aligned with how your employees will likely access their benefits? Consider:
- Whether your default investment strategy reflects current market conditions.
- If the fund’s risk profile matches your workforce demographics.
- Whether the charges represent good value compared to current market offerings.
Read: Three things that will make your pension provision better for more ideas on how to improve your pension provision for your employees.
Red Flag #3: You lack independent governance
Pension governance is an essential protection for your business and employees. Without robust, independent oversight, issues can go undetected for years, potentially leading to suboptimal outcomes and even regulatory problems.
Effective governance should include:
- Regular performance reviews against appropriate benchmarks.
- Assessment of value for money.
- Ensuring regulatory compliance.
- Assessment of the effectiveness of member communication.
- Input from various stakeholders within your business.
How Bravo Benefits can help you review and improve your workplace pension
Identifying one of these red flags doesn’t automatically mean you need to replace your pension provider.
It simply means that you need enough information to understand whether your current arrangement is still delivering the right outcomes.
Bravo Benefits provides an independent Business Pension Consultancy service designed to help employers review, improve and manage their workplace pension scheme.
Rather than looking at your pension purely from a compliance perspective, our pension consultants consider how effectively the scheme is working for both your organisation and your employees.
1. Start with a full pension review
The first step is understanding exactly what you already have.
We can review areas including:
- Provider performance and charges.
- Default funds and investment options.
- Governance and compliance.
- Employee engagement and communications.
This gives you a clearer picture of where your scheme is performing well and where there may be opportunities to improve.
2. Benchmark your scheme against the wider market
Being with the same pension provider for several years doesn’t necessarily mean you need to change. But it does make it important to check whether your existing arrangement still represents good value.
As an independent consultancy, Bravo Benefits can benchmark your scheme against the wider pension market and assess areas such as provider costs, investment options and available support. This means our recommendations are based on what is most appropriate for your organisation and its employees.
3. Review salary exchange opportunities
If you haven’t implemented salary exchange, or your existing arrangement hasn’t been reviewed recently, our consultants will review your arrangements to ensure they have been established in the most effective way possible.
This can include reviewing contribution structures and modelling potential National Insurance savings for the organisation.
The objective isn’t simply to reduce costs; it’s to make sure your pension arrangement works as efficiently as possible for both employer and employee.
Our team will help explain how salary exchange works to your employees. Communications are key to the successful implementation of a salary exchange project.
4. Put ongoing governance in place
A pension review shouldn’t be something you do once and forget about for another decade.
Our team can provide ongoing scheme reviews, market benchmarking, governance support, provider performance monitoring and relevant legislative and market updates.
That gives your organisation an ongoing framework for checking that the scheme continues to perform as expected. It also provides reassurance to the scheme members that the performance of your scheme is being monitored.
5. Help employees understand the benefit you’re providing
It’s our experience that even a well-designed workplace pension has limited value as an employee benefit if employees don’t understand it.
That’s why our pension consultancy service also includes support that helps your employees engage with their pension and understand their different options.
This can include employee presentations, workshops, straightforward communications and ongoing pension education.
Helping employees better understand their pension can turn something that often feels distant or complicated into a much more visible part of your wider financial wellbeing strategy.
Turn your workplace pension into a more valuable employee benefit
Workplace pensions are a legal requirement, but that doesn’t mean their value should stop at compliance.
As part of a workplace financial wellbeing strategy, a well-managed pension scheme can help support employees’ long-term financial wellbeing, whilst also giving employers opportunities to improve value, manage costs and strengthen their overall benefits package.
And importantly, reviewing your pension doesn’t automatically mean changing everything.
Sometimes the outcome of an independent review will be confirmation that your existing provider and structure remain appropriate.
In other cases, it might reveal opportunities to improve investments, charges, salary exchange, governance, employee engagement or provider support.
The important thing is knowing.
If your scheme hasn’t been reviewed recently, or you’ve recognised any of the three red flags above, find out more about Bravo Benefits’ Business Pension Consultancy and see how our pension consultants can help you build a clearer, better governed and more effective workplace pension strategy.
Unlock hidden value: Transform your pension today
The pension provider market has transformed dramatically in recent years, with innovative investment options, advanced technology, and evolving regulatory requirements reshaping the landscape. What qualified as industry best practice just a few years ago may now be leaving significant value on the table.
By addressing these red flags promptly, you can unlock hidden value within your pension scheme that benefits both your business’s bottom line and your employees’ financial futures.
Remember, effective pension management isn’t a one-time task – it’s an ongoing commitment that yields compounding returns over time. Contact us today to discuss how we can help you navigate these common pitfalls and transform your pension scheme into a truly valuable asset for everyone involved.





