Opens in a new tab

How to Choose an How To Choose A Employee Benefits Consultant: A Guide

A woman considers how to choose an employee benefits consultant and discusses it with two friends

When deciding what employee benefits consultant to choose, first consider whether you want a consultant or a broker. A consultant takes a broader view, considering how individual benefits fit within your overall strategy. When assessing consultants, check that they consider what your problem is, and how the benefits they recommend are going to help solve that problem. Consider to what degree they get to know your company and struggles too. A good consultant should help support you throughout the year, not just at renewal. They should be able to explain why a provider is a good fit for your business, not just recommend their favourites and should also be able to take some of the benefits adminsitration off your plate if required.

If you’re trusting someone to advise you on thousands of pounds of employee benefits, what should you actually expect from them?

A competitive renewal? Of course, but that should only be part of the picture.

The right employee benefits consultant should understand your business, challenge what isn’t working and help you make better decisions about where your benefits budget goes. They should be able to tell you whether your current package still makes sense, where there may be gaps or duplication, and whether employees are actually getting enough value from what you provide. That matters, because choosing a consultant isn’t simply choosing someone to find products and negotiate with providers. You’re choosing an adviser who could influence your benefits strategy, employee experience and HR workload for years to come.

So, how do you tell the difference between consultants who appear to offer broadly similar services? It helps to look beyond the sales presentation and ask better questions.

This guide covers what an employee benefits consultant should actually do, what to look for when comparing consultants, the questions worth asking before you appoint one and the warning signs that could suggest they’re not the right fit.

What should an employee benefits consultant actually do?

Before comparing consultants, it helps to know what you should expect from the relationship.

At its simplest, an employee benefits consultant helps employers plan, review, implement and manage their employee benefits. But good employee benefits consulting should go further than approaching providers and presenting you with a selection of products.

Your consultant might help you:

  • Review your existing benefits and identify gaps, duplication or areas that could work harder.
  • Build a benefits strategy around your workforce and business priorities.
  • Research and compare products and providers.
  • Support negotiations and renewals.
  • Advise on health and wellbeing, pensions and group risk and protection.
  • Introduce technology that makes benefits easier to access and manage.
  • Improve how you communicate benefits to employees.
  • Reduce some of the day-to-day administration involved in running your schemes.
  • Use engagement, utilisation and other available data to understand how your benefits are performing.

The important point is that those services shouldn’t exist in isolation. Your consultant should be able to join the dots between them.

For example, there’s little value in introducing a new benefit if employees don’t know it exists. Equally, a benefit might look good on paper but create unnecessary administration for HR, duplicate something you already provide or simply not reflect what your workforce needs. A consultant should help you see that bigger picture.

Employee benefits consultant or broker: Does the title matter?

You may come across both employee benefits consultants and brokers when looking for support, and there can be considerable overlap between the two. Traditionally, a broker’s role has focused more heavily on sourcing products, approaching insurers or providers and helping employers secure suitable terms. Employee benefits consulting can take a broader view, considering how individual benefits fit within your overall reward, wellbeing and people strategy.

In reality, the name alone won’t tell you what level of service you’re going to receive.

A better approach is to ask what your adviser will actually do for you.

  • Will they simply approach the market at renewal, or will they also challenge whether the benefit is still right for your workforce? 
  • Can they help with technology, communication and administration? 
  • Will they look across your entire package to identify gaps or duplication?

The answers to those questions are likely to tell you far more than the title on a business card.

Start with what you actually need

Before comparing consultants, think about what has prompted you to look for support in the first place. Perhaps your benefits have grown over time without a clear strategy behind them. Maybe renewals are taking up too much internal resource, employees aren’t engaging with what you offer, or you’re unsure whether you’re getting good value from your existing arrangements.

Or perhaps the business has simply changed. What worked when you employed 50 people may not work when you employ 200.

It can help to identify the issues you most want to address:

  • Recruitment and retention.
  • Rising benefit costs.
  • Low employee awareness or engagement.
  • Too much benefits administration for HR.
  • Poor visibility of how benefits are being used.
  • Disconnected providers or systems.
  • Gaps in health and wellbeing support.
  • Pension or protection requirements.
  • A benefits package that hasn’t kept pace with the workforce.
  • A lack of clear strategy behind what you offer.

You don’t need to diagnose every problem yourself; a good consultant should help you identify where improvements can be.

Can they think beyond individual benefits?

Once you know what you need, look at how each consultant approaches strategy.

Most employee benefits consultants can give you access to products. The more useful question is how they decide which products, providers or changes are appropriate for you.

A consultant should take time to understand your business before recommending solutions. That could include your business objectives, workforce demographics, existing benefits, budget, employee feedback, engagement levels, HR resources, and plans for growth.

If every conversation quickly becomes a list of additional products you could introduce, ask why those particular benefits are being suggested.

The aim shouldn’t be to create the longest possible list of benefits, but to create a package with a clear purpose behind it.

Can they support more than the next renewal?

Your needs are unlikely to fit neatly into one area of employee benefits, so it’s worth looking at the breadth of expertise available to you.

For example, you might initially approach a consultant because your Private Medical Insurance renewal is coming up. But that conversation could reveal wider questions around absence, employee wellbeing, communication or whether other forms of healthcare support could complement your existing provision.

Depending on your business, you may need expertise across areas such as:

Health and wellbeing: including Private Medical Insurance, Health Cash Plans, Employee Assistance Programmes, 24/7 GP services, health screening and wider wellbeing strategy.

Group risk and protection: including Group Life Assurance, Group Income Protection and Critical Illness cover.

Pensions: including pension consultancy, employee education and salary exchange arrangements where appropriate.

Reward and recognition: helping you recognise employees and strengthen the visibility of the overall reward package.

Financial wellbeing: providing support that can help employees better understand and manage their finances.

Technology: bringing benefits together and helping employees access them more easily.

Communication: making sure employees understand what they have and how to use it.

Administration: supporting the ongoing work involved in running your benefits.

You may not need support across all of these areas today, but your requirements can change, and having access to broader expertise can make it easier to adapt your approach as your business develops.

Look closely at how they choose providers

Being told that a consultant has access to a wide range of providers can sound reassuring. But access alone doesn’t tell you how those providers will be assessed.

Ask how the selection process actually works. A good recommendation should have a clear rationale behind it. Your consultant should be able to explain why a particular product or provider is suitable for your organisation and what alternatives were considered.

Depending on the benefit, factors such as service, cover, employee experience, implementation, claims processes and ongoing support could all influence value. The cheapest option isn’t necessarily the one that will work best for your business.

This is also where evidence becomes important. Rather than simply hearing that one option is “better”, ask what that assessment is based on and how the consultant has reached their recommendation. You should come away understanding the decision, not simply being asked to approve it.

Find out what happens at renewal

Renewal is one of the points at which you should see the value of your employee benefits consultant most clearly. So, ask what their renewal process actually involves.

Do they simply obtain terms from your existing provider? Do they test the market where appropriate? What information do they analyse? How do they decide whether staying with the existing arrangement represents good value?

Depending on the benefit, a meaningful review might consider areas such as:

  • Current cost and proposed increases.
  • Claims or utilisation information where available.
  • Changes to your workforce.
  • Employee needs and feedback.
  • Service from the existing provider.
  • Alternative options in the market.
  • Whether the benefit still fits your wider strategy.

It’s also worth asking when that work begins because leaving everything until a renewal deadline can limit the time available to understand your options properly. A consultant who plans ahead can give you more opportunity to assess the current arrangement and make an informed decision rather than simply reacting to the renewal terms.

What evidence will they give you?

This is one of the most useful areas to explore when comparing employee benefits consultants.

Plenty of advisers can tell you they’ll improve engagement, reduce administration or help you get more value from your benefits. Ask how they’ll demonstrate it.

For example:

  • What reporting will you receive?
  • What engagement or utilisation data will be available?
  • Can they establish a baseline before changes are made?
  • How will they assess whether communications are working?
  • Can they demonstrate how their recommendations have helped other employers?
  • How will they review progress throughout the year?
  • What will they use to demonstrate value at your next annual review?

Not every benefit can or should be judged by exactly the same metric, but there should be some way of understanding what is happening. If a consultant says they can improve an area of your benefits strategy, they should be able to explain how you’ll know whether it has improved.

How good is their technology and do you actually need it?

Technology is now a significant part of many employee benefits propositions, but a platform shouldn’t be introduced simply because one is available. We recommend you always start with the problem it’s supposed to solve.

For employees, an effective platform could make it easier to see what benefits are available and how to access them. For HR, it could centralise information, support communications and provide better visibility of engagement.

When comparing technology, consider:

  • Can your existing benefits be included?
  • Is it straightforward for employees to use?
  • Can communications be personalised?
  • What reporting and analytics are available?
  • What implementation support is included?
  • Can it scale as your organisation grows?
  • How does it integrate with your existing processes or systems?
  • What security measures are in place?
  • Who provides ongoing support?

Most importantly, ask how employees will be encouraged to use it after launch. A platform that looks impressive in a demonstration but is rarely visited six months later isn’t necessarily solving the problem.

Will they help employees understand their benefits?

Offering a benefit and getting value from it are two different things. If employees don’t know what is available, don’t understand why it might be useful or can’t remember how to access it, even a strong benefits package can struggle to deliver its full value.

That’s why employee communication should be part of the conversation when choosing a consultant.

Ask what communication support is actually included. Will employees hear about their benefits only when something launches? Or will there be communication throughout the year?

Support might include emails, guides, campaigns, webinars, platform notifications or communications built around relevant moments in the employee journey.

Then take the conversation one step further: how will you know whether those communications are working?

That might involve looking at email engagement, platform activity, benefit utilisation or employee feedback, depending on what you’re trying to achieve. Communication shouldn’t simply be something that is sent. It should help employees take action.

Find out what they’ll actually take off your plate

This is particularly important if one of your reasons for looking for a consultant is pressure on your HR team. There’s a big difference between receiving advice about employee benefits and receiving practical support while managing them.

Day-to-day administration can include starters and leavers, eligibility changes, provider queries, employee questions, records and ongoing scheme changes. With several providers involved, seemingly small tasks can quickly add up.

Rather than asking whether administration support is available, ask exactly what the consultant will take responsibility for.

Who deals with providers when an employee has a problem? Who processes changes? Who answers employee queries? Who keeps information up to date? And what will still sit with your internal team?

If a consultant says their service will reduce administration, ask them to show you how.

Understanding those responsibilities before you appoint someone can prevent confusion later.

Pay attention to the questions they ask you

You’ll naturally arrive at a meeting with plenty of questions for a potential consultant, but pay just as much attention to what they ask you.

Meaningful advice requires information. Depending on the work involved, a consultant may want to understand your:

  • Existing benefits and providers.
  • Current costs and renewal dates.
  • Workforce size and demographics.
  • Business and people priorities.
  • Recruitment and retention challenges.
  • Employee feedback.
  • Benefits utilisation and engagement.
  • Relevant absence or wellbeing challenges.
  • Existing HR systems and processes.
  • Internal resources for managing benefits.
  • Plans for growth or organisational change.

Not every review will require all of this information, and the level of detail should be proportionate to what you’ve asked the consultant to do. But there should be a genuine discovery process. If you’re receiving detailed recommendations before anyone has properly understood your workforce, objectives or current arrangements, it’s reasonable to ask what those recommendations are based on.

Make sure you understand how they’re paid

Cost is an important part of any supplier decision, but make sure you understand more than the headline number. Ask how the consultant is remunerated and what is included within the proposed service. Depending on the arrangement and benefit involved, remuneration structures can differ. What matters from a comparison perspective is understanding what you are paying for and what you will receive in return.

For example:

  • What is included in ongoing consultancy?
  • Are there separate charges for particular services?
  • Is technology included?
  • Is communication support included?
  • What administration will they provide?
  • Are there implementation charges?
  • How will remuneration be explained to you?

Without that information, comparing two proposals can be difficult because what initially looks like the cheaper option may not include the same level of service.

The questions worth asking before you appoint a consultant

By this point, you should have a much clearer idea of what you want to test.

Using the same core questions with each consultant can make it much easier to compare proposals fairly.

What to exploreWhat to ask
StrategyHow will you understand our business and workforce before making recommendations?
Existing benefitsHow will you assess what we already have and identify gaps or duplication?
Provider selectionHow do you compare providers, and what evidence supports your recommendations?
RenewalsWhat does your renewal process involve and when do you start?
CostHow are you paid and exactly what is included?
TechnologyWhat technology would you recommend for us, and why?
CommunicationWhat employee communication support is included and how will you measure engagement?
AdministrationWhat work will you actually take away from our internal team?
ExpertiseWhat specialist support can you provide across pensions, health, wellbeing and protection?
ReportingWhat information will we receive to understand whether our benefits are working?
ServiceWho will we deal with day to day and what service levels should we expect?
ImplementationIf we decide to make changes, who will manage the process?

Red flags worth investigating

No single employee benefits consultancy model will be right for every employer, and something that matters enormously to one organisation may be less important to another.

There are, however, a few situations where it’s worth asking more questions.

Be cautious if:

  • Recommendations are being made before the consultant has taken time to understand your business.
  • Most conversations revolve around products rather than what you’re trying to achieve.
  • The consultant can’t clearly explain why a particular provider has been recommended.
  • Fees or remuneration are difficult to understand.
  • You’re unclear about what ongoing support is included.
  • Communication and employee engagement receive little attention.
  • Technology is presented as the solution without much discussion about implementation or adoption.
  • Claims about improving value, engagement or administration aren’t supported by an explanation of how those improvements will be assessed.
  • You don’t know who will actually look after your account once the sales process is over.
  • The relationship appears to revolve almost entirely around annual renewals.

These points don’t automatically mean a consultant is unsuitable. But they do give you useful areas to investigate before making a decision.

How do you compare employee benefits consultants?

Once you’ve spoken to several consultants, you may have proposals that look very different.

One may appear cheaper. Another may offer more technology. Another might provide much more administration or communication support. That makes a like-for-like comparison important.

Rather than trying to identify the consultant with the longest list of services, bring the decision back to the priorities you identified at the beginning.

You could compare each proposal across:

  • Strategic support.
  • Relevant specialist expertise.
  • Provider and product selection.
  • Renewal support.
  • Technology.
  • Employee communication.
  • Administration.
  • Reporting and evidence.
  • Implementation support.
  • Day-to-day service.
  • Cost and remuneration transparency.

Then look at what sits behind the promises. If a consultant says they provide proactive service, what will that actually involve? If they promise better engagement, how will they support and measure it? If they say they’ll save HR time, which tasks will they take over?

The more specific you can make the comparison, the easier it becomes to understand what you’re actually buying.

When is it time to review your current consultant?

Looking at the market doesn’t have to mean you’re unhappy with your existing employee benefits consultant. Sometimes your business has simply moved on.

A consultancy arrangement that worked well several years ago may no longer provide the support you need as your workforce, benefits package or internal HR team changes.

It could be worth reviewing your current arrangements if:

  • Your workforce has grown or changed significantly.
  • Your benefits have developed without an overall strategy.
  • Costs are increasing and you don’t have enough insight into why.
  • Employees have low awareness or engagement.
  • HR is spending too much time administering benefits.
  • You have multiple providers but little coordination between them.
  • You receive limited reporting or insight.
  • You hear from your consultant mainly around renewal.
  • You’re planning significant changes to your benefits.
  • It has simply been a long time since you reviewed the service you receive.

A review doesn’t automatically mean changing consultants. It might confirm that your existing relationship is working well. Or it may identify areas where the service could be improved.

Either way, you have a clearer understanding of what you’re receiving and what you need next.

Look for more than a supplier?

Choosing an employee benefits consultant shouldn’t come down to who can present the longest list of benefits or the lowest headline cost. You’re choosing someone to help you make decisions about an important investment in your people.

The right relationship should leave you with a clearer understanding of what you’re spending, what employees are receiving and where your benefits strategy could work harder.

And if you haven’t reviewed your current approach for a while, that can be a useful place to start.

Bravo Benefits can help you review your existing employee benefits strategy and consultancy support, identify opportunities for improvement and consider what your organisation may need next. Talk to us about reviewing your employee benefits strategy and current consultancy support.

About the author...

Adele Oakden
Head of Health and Wellbeing and Head of Client Success
Full Bio
Linkedin profile